Is The Good Doctor Really Autistic?

June 27, 2024

Portrayal in "The Good Doctor"

"The Good Doctor" has sparked discussions about the portrayal of autism in the media, raising questions about the accuracy and authenticity of the portrayal. It is important to analyze both the broader context of autism representation in media and the specific character of Dr. Shaun Murphy.

Autism Representation in Media

Autism representation in media plays a crucial role in shaping public understanding and perception of individuals on the autism spectrum. It is essential for these portrayals to accurately reflect the experiences and diversity within the autism community. While "The Good Doctor" has garnered attention for its representation of autism, it is not without critique. Autistic adults who reviewed the show expressed mixed opinions, highlighting both positives and areas for improvement.

Dr. Shaun Murphy's Character

In "The Good Doctor," Dr. Shaun Murphy, portrayed by Freddie Highmore, is a surgical resident with autism and savant syndrome. The character illustrates the challenges faced by individuals on the autism spectrum, as well as their strengths and unique perspectives. The portrayal attempts to emphasize that autism does not equate to intellectual disability and that individuals on the spectrum can excel in various areas of life, including attending college, pursuing advanced degrees, and working in demanding professions.

"The Good Doctor" has been commended for striking a delicate balance between portraying autism realistically and avoiding the trap of producing "inspiration porn." The show highlights characteristics that can accompany an autism diagnosis, resonating with many in the autism community.

However, it is important to acknowledge that "The Good Doctor" represents one example of autism, and no single portrayal can encompass the entire spectrum of experiences. The character of Dr. Shaun Murphy provides one perspective and representation of autism, but it is crucial to recognize the diversity within the autistic community. To achieve more accurate and inclusive portrayals, it is essential to involve autistic individuals in the creation and production of such media content, as expressed by reviewers.

By critically examining the portrayal of autism in "The Good Doctor," we can gain insights into the broader conversation surrounding autism representation in the media. It is important to continue advocating for diverse and informed depictions of autism, challenging stereotypes, and promoting a deeper understanding of the experiences and capabilities of individuals on the spectrum.

Critiques and Praises

When it comes to the portrayal of autism in the television show "The Good Doctor," opinions are divided, according to reviews by autistic adults. Some individuals felt that the representation of autism in the show was too general and did not capture the full range of experiences and positivity exuded by individuals on the spectrum. It was suggested that the show could benefit from having more autistic individuals involved in portraying autistic characters in the media.

However, there is also appreciation for the lead actor, Freddie Highmore, who plays the character of Dr. Shaun Murphy. Highmore's performance has been widely recognized and applauded. He brings depth and authenticity to the role, effectively conveying the challenges and strengths of an individual with autism. Highmore's portrayal has resonated with many viewers and has helped raise awareness and understanding of autism [3].

It is important to note that the opinions expressed by autistic individuals and their families can vary. In the case of the show "Atypical," a Netflix series that also depicts a character with autism, a study found that the majority of participants considered the portrayal accurate, with family members perceiving informative benefits and improved attitudes toward autism compared to autistic individuals themselves.

Overall, while "The Good Doctor" has received mixed reviews from the autism community, it has sparked conversations and shed light on the experiences of individuals with autism. The show has been commended for navigating the delicate balance of portraying autistic characters realistically without falling into the trap of producing "inspiration porn." It strives to show the diversity within the autistic community, acknowledging that no two individuals manifest their autism in the same way.

By encouraging more representation and involvement of autistic individuals in the media, we can move closer to accurate and nuanced portrayals that reflect the full spectrum of experiences and challenge misconceptions surrounding autism. It is essential to continue advocating for diversity and empowering autistic individuals to tell their own stories.

Depth of Portrayal

When examining the portrayal of autism in "The Good Doctor," it becomes evident that the show aimed to strike a balance between realism and sensitivity. The character of Dr. Shaun Murphy, played by Freddie Highmore, has sparked discussions and debates surrounding the representation of autism in the media.

Balancing Realism and Sensitivity

"The Good Doctor" has made interesting choices in visually representing the inner workings of Shaun Murphy's mind, showcasing his savant abilities and unique thought processes. While this artistic approach captures attention, it is important to note that it may not reflect the experiences of all individuals on the autism spectrum. Critics argue that there is a need for more careful and varied representations of savant syndrome and autism in media to avoid perpetuating stereotypes.

Despite these considerations, the show has been commended for shedding light on the daily challenges faced by individuals with autism and the importance of understanding and acceptance [5]. By portraying Shaun Murphy as a multi-dimensional character, "The Good Doctor" aims to challenge societal perceptions of individuals who think and behave differently.

Challenges in Character Development

Creating a character like Dr. Shaun Murphy, who exhibits traits commonly associated with autism, presented unique challenges in character development. The show's creators and actors have shared their insights into the portrayal, emphasizing their intentions to depict a complex individual with exceptional abilities and challenges, rather than specifically representing autism.

By avoiding an explicit statement that Shaun Murphy is on the autism spectrum, the show aims to highlight neurodiversity and emphasize that individuals who think and behave differently should be celebrated and included in society. This approach allows viewers to connect with the character beyond a label and encourages a deeper understanding of the experiences of people with autism.

"The Good Doctor" has resonated with many in the autism community, as it portrays characteristics that can accompany an autism diagnosis, such as difficulties with social interactions, repetitive behaviors, and a heightened focus on details. By capturing these characteristics, the show creates relatable moments and fosters empathy and understanding among viewers.

As the portrayal of autism in media continues to evolve, it is important to engage in ongoing conversations that advocate for accurate and diverse representations. By challenging stereotypes and promoting inclusivity, we can move towards a more comprehensive understanding of autism and create a more accepting society.

Impact on Viewers

"The Good Doctor" has made a significant impact on viewers, particularly parents of children with autism. The show has elicited both emotional responses and provided educational value, creating a platform for awareness and understanding.

Emotional Responses

Viewers have experienced a range of emotional responses while watching "The Good Doctor". The discussion in the show about whether individuals with autism lack empathy, followed by scenes where Dr. Shaun Murphy demonstrates his ability to care for others, has been particularly moving and impactful. These scenes challenge the misconception that people with autism lack empathy and showcase the depth of emotions that individuals on the autism spectrum can experience.

Additionally, the character of Dr. Glassman in "The Good Doctor" emphasizes the importance of treating people with respect and giving opportunities to those with limitations. This portrayal highlights the significance of hiring individuals with disabilities, like Dr. Murphy, and provides hope to those facing limitations. The representation of characters with autism who are capable, caring, and successful evokes powerful emotions and serves as an inspiration for viewers.

Educational Value

"The Good Doctor" provides educational value by increasing awareness and understanding of autism. The show has been praised for its portrayal of Dr. Shaun Murphy's unique way of thinking, such as thinking in pictures, which is depicted on screen when he visualizes the human body or recalls specific information. This portrayal adds depth to the character and showcases different ways of processing information.

Through its depiction of Dr. Murphy and the challenges he faces, "The Good Doctor" also educates viewers about the daily struggles and strengths of individuals on the autism spectrum. The show aims to challenge stereotypes and provide hope to individuals with disabilities, highlighting their capabilities and potential.

By portraying autism in a realistic and sensitive manner, "The Good Doctor" offers viewers an opportunity to gain insights into the experiences of individuals on the autism spectrum. It fosters understanding, empathy, and acceptance, making a positive impact on the way autism is perceived in society.

As viewers continue to engage with "The Good Doctor", they can further explore autism and its various aspects, gain knowledge about available resources, and contribute to creating a more inclusive and supportive environment for individuals with autism and their families.

Moving Beyond Stereotypes

When it comes to portraying autism in the media, it is essential to move beyond stereotypes and advocate for diversity and accuracy in representation. By doing so, we can address misconceptions surrounding autism and promote a more inclusive understanding of the condition.

Advocating for Diversity

One of the key aspects in portraying autism authentically is advocating for diversity. Participants in a study emphasized the need for increased diversity in representations of autism in entertainment media. This includes showcasing different gender expressions, racial backgrounds, socioeconomic statuses, and a broader representation of the autism spectrum. It is crucial to involve autistic individuals in the development and production process of such portrayals to ensure authenticity and avoid perpetuating stereotypes.

By showcasing the diversity within the autism community, media representations can help dismantle preconceived notions and promote acceptance and understanding among viewers. It allows for a more accurate reflection of the experiences and strengths of individuals on the autism spectrum.

Addressing Autism Misconceptions

Another important aspect of moving beyond stereotypes is addressing misconceptions about autism. Some portrayals in the media have been criticized for perpetuating stereotypes and inaccurate beliefs about autism, which can contribute to stigma and negative attitudes. It is crucial to challenge these misconceptions and provide accurate information to the public.

By portraying autism in a nuanced and realistic manner, media can help dispel myths and promote a better understanding of the condition. This involves showcasing the diverse range of abilities, challenges, and strengths individuals with autism possess. It can also highlight the importance of creating inclusive environments that support individuals on the autism spectrum.

To ensure accurate portrayals, it is important to involve autistic individuals and consult with experts in the field of autism when developing and producing media content. By doing so, media representations can contribute to a more informed and empathetic society.

By advocating for diversity and addressing misconceptions, media portrayals of autism can play a vital role in promoting acceptance, understanding, and inclusion. It is essential to move beyond stereotypes and present authentic and diverse portrayals that reflect the lived experiences of individuals on the autism spectrum.

Looking at Other Portrayals

When examining the portrayal of autism in popular media, it's important to consider other notable examples beyond "The Good Doctor." Two prominent portrayals that have sparked discussions within the autism community are Sheldon Cooper from "The Big Bang Theory" and the broader representation of autism across various platforms.

Critiques of Sheldon Cooper

Sheldon Cooper, a character from the hit television show "The Big Bang Theory," has received mixed reviews from individuals with autism. Some individuals feel that Sheldon's portrayal is an exaggerated and negative representation of autism [2]. Criticisms include the portrayal of Sheldon's extreme intelligence as a justification for negative traits like arrogance, a lack of social cues, and abrasive behavior. These traits do not align with the experiences of many autistic individuals and can perpetuate stereotypes.

It's important to note that Sheldon Cooper's character was never explicitly stated to be autistic in the show. However, his behaviors and characteristics have drawn comparisons to autism due to his unique way of interacting with others and his rigid adherence to routines.

Autism Spectrum Representation

Autism is a spectrum with diverse characteristics and traits, and capturing this broad range in a single portrayal can be challenging. The need to exaggerate certain characteristics in portrayals, such as in "The Good Doctor," is often done to make autism recognizable to a general audience that may be less familiar with the condition. However, it is important to remember that there is significant variation among individuals on the spectrum, and not all autistic individuals exhibit the same traits or behaviors.

Efforts have been made to improve the representation of autism in media by showcasing a wider range of experiences and highlighting the diversity within the autism community. By featuring characters with different backgrounds and abilities, media can contribute to a more accurate and inclusive representation of autism.

As discussions surrounding autism representation in media continue to evolve, it is crucial to advocate for diverse and authentic portrayals that accurately reflect the experiences of individuals on the spectrum. This can help challenge misconceptions and promote a deeper understanding of autism among the general public.

By critically examining portrayals like those of Sheldon Cooper and exploring a broader range of representations, we can contribute to a more nuanced and informed conversation about autism in popular media.